Lyle was signed from Hayes & Yeading United, making his debut – and scoring – in a 5-3 win against Haringey Borough in December 2019. He started out with Tottenham Hotspur as a youth before moving on to Southend United and Fulham, where he signed his first professional contract aged 17. After a loan spell at Bristol Rovers, he subsequently signed for Fleetwood Town and then Crawley Town before moving into non-league football with Welling United, Concord Rangers and Dartford. After starting last year at Braintree Town, he transferred to Kingstonian via Haringey Borough in March 2019.